The performance of “Stop Draggin’ My Heart Around” by Carrie Underwood and Keith Urban at the American Idol finale on April 7, 2016, was a show-stopping duet that celebrated the series’ influence in pop and country music. This powerful rendition of the classic originally by Stevie Nicks and Tom Petty showcased Underwood’s dynamic voice and Urban’s skilled guitar playing. Urban, who had served as a judge on the show, started the performance solo, with Underwood joining him on stage as the two traded verses with electric chemistry.

Fans and critics alike praised the duet as a highlight of the night. Urban, dressed sharply in a suit, and Underwood delivered a rendition with a rock edge that combined their country roots with a gritty, nostalgic vibe, reminiscent of the original rock tune’s spirit. The performance was especially sentimental, as Underwood was American Idol’s first major country star winner, winning Season 4, while Urban had become a beloved judge, contributing to the show’s later seasons. The duet was part of a star-studded finale, which included other memorable moments and past winners from the show’s 15 seasons, marking a heartfelt farewell to the series’ run on Fox.

Their performance resonated with the audience as a nod to Idol’s legacy of blending genres and bringing big-name artists and rising talents to the spotlight. Underwood and Urban, who later collaborated on “The Fighter,” left fans with a sense of the show’s lasting impact on the music industry, particularly for country artists who found their start on the American Idol stage​.