Islam Makhachev, Alex Pereira, and UFC 306 Brawl Leave Bloody Elbow Staff Divided on Fight of the Year Award
The Case for Islam Makhachev
Islam Makhachev’s lightweight title defense against Charles Oliveira at UFC 294 was a masterclass in strategy and skill. Makhachev showcased his grappling dominance while adding another layer to his striking repertoire, solidifying his status as one of the most complete fighters in the sport.
Bloody Elbow’s senior analyst, Jake Donaldson, argued that the fight exemplified perfection in MMA, stating, “Makhachev’s performance was not only technically flawless but also historically significant. Beating a submission artist like Oliveira in his own game was nothing short of brilliance.”
For fans who value technical proficiency, Makhachev’s victory stands as the gold standard for the year.
Alex Pereira’s Epic Redemption
On the other side of the debate, Alex Pereira’s clash with Jiri Prochazka at UFC 295 delivered a spectacle of raw power and resilience. The former middleweight champion moved up to light heavyweight to take on Prochazka in what turned out to be a back-and-forth war. Pereira’s ability to absorb punishment and deliver devastating counterattacks highlighted his evolution as a fighter.
“Pereira-Prochazka was pure chaos in the best possible way,” noted Bloody Elbow editor Sarah Kline. “This was the kind of fight that had you on the edge of your seat, unsure of who would walk away with the win until the very last moment.”
For those who prize drama and heart, this fight is an undeniable contender.
The UFC 306 Brawl
Adding a twist to the “Fight of the Year” conversation is the unsanctioned melee that erupted backstage at UFC 306. While not a fight in the traditional sense, the chaotic scene involving several fighters, cornermen, and security personnel captivated fans and critics alike. The brawl reportedly stemmed from tensions between rival camps and escalated into a full-blown spectacle that overshadowed the event itself.
“It might not be what the award was designed for, but there’s no denying the impact of the UFC 306 brawl,” argued staff writer Ethan Harris. “It was the kind of moment that had everyone talking, for better or worse.”
A Divided Staff
While some Bloody Elbow staff lean towards recognizing Makhachev’s technical brilliance, others argue that Pereira’s war and the chaos of UFC 306 encapsulated the unpredictable spirit of MMA. The division highlights a broader question about what truly defines a “Fight of the Year—is it skill, excitement, or cultural impact?
As fans eagerly await the final decision, one thing is clear: 2024 will have big shoes to fill. The moments that defined 2023 in MMA were nothing short of spectacular, leaving an indelible mark on the sport’s history.
What’s your pick for Fight of the Year? Join the debate and share your thoughts!