Jim Carrey’s surprising and heartfelt cover of Radiohead’s “Creep” at Arlene’s Grocery in New York in 2011 captivated fans and quickly went viral, accumulating millions of views online. Known primarily as a comedic actor, Carrey took on the iconic Radiohead song during a rock karaoke night, bringing an intensity and authenticity that highlighted his depth as a performer. In a blend of humor and raw emotion, he introduced the song with a grin, calling it his “new anthem.” As he began singing, Carrey embraced the melancholy lyrics with a sincere, almost haunting rendition that resonated powerfully with the audience.

This performance showcased Carrey’s surprising vocal range, hitting the high notes in the song’s bridge with an emotional delivery that underscored his connection to the lyrics. His passion was evident, as fans noted his ability to move from a lighthearted start to a soulful performance, tapping into the themes of alienation and vulnerability that have made “Creep” a lasting anthem. The crowd’s enthusiasm for Carrey’s emotive portrayal added to the intimate energy of the evening​.

Arlene’s Grocery, a well-known Lower East Side music venue, has hosted major artists like The Strokes and Lady Gaga in their early days. Carrey’s appearance there with the venue’s house band was a memorable moment for fans, showcasing his artistic versatility and a side of him that few had seen before.